Think about the choices that each character makes and the external circumstances that limit the character’s choices. Change ). UH. Ethan Frome delivers neither a positive message or a negative message. (tone, morals, contrasts), Is suicide ever a viable option? They believe that they soul mates. Her mind was a store-house of in-nocuous anecdote and any question about her acquaintances brought forth a volume of de-tail; but on the subject of Ethan Frome I found her unexpectedly reticent. Who is the real villain of the story? What impressions/interpretations does the author try to make about the concept of love and relationships in the novel? Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. How would the impact of Starkfield have been different if both had perished? Week 3: Read Act III. Throughout the book he feels as though she is holding him back from happiness, which he feels is to be with Mattie. Responding to the Selection In a few words, describe your opinion of reach of the following charac - ters: Ethan Frome, Zeena Frome… What could have turned out differently if Zeena had not been such a closed off person? What could have turned out differently if Zeena had not been such a closed off person? Prepare for your Socratic Seminar, which will be on 2/18/16. Why does the author make the initial contrast between her and Zeena so great? Synopsis of Ethan Frome A classic novel of despair, forbidden emotion, ... Socratic Seminar - Socratic Seminar Socrates (June 4, ca. Repetitive patterns of imagery are an important part of Ethan Frome. STUDY. The book gives an illustration of a life, though it is not filed with happiness, the characters helped to put themselves in the position they are now stuck in forever. Discuss the three characters. A Socratic seminar is a “collaborative, intellectual dialogue facilitated by open ended questions about a text.” - From the National Paideia Center A Socratic seminar will always address the CCSS standards for speaking and listening and will extend a lesson to include higher order thinking skills Out of class reading: Gender stereotype essays. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. The Frome Family Talk Show- Role playing activity in which the students arrange for the Fromes and Mattie to guests on a talk show (like Dr. Phil). How does all this symbolism come together to create meaning? As stated by Mrs. Hale in the ending of the book, “There was one day, about a week after the accident, when they all Thought Mattie couldn’t live. Socratic Seminar Questions Core/Essential Questions: What imp… Discuss Mattie's and Ethan's decision in the sleigh—an act of … Hmwk: Socratic Seminar reflection. The Question and Answer sections of our study guides are a great resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss literature. Opening Questions Core Questions Analyze the text Start discussing theme What do you think defines honor is Beowulf's society? If Mattie was a stronger character, would Zeena still feel as though she had control in her household? Why are Mattie and Ethan drawn to each other? Symbolism is used heavily throughout the novel in relation to the harsh environment of Starkfield, Massachusetts. Zeena is described as having a “sallow face” and harsh feature, whereas Mattie is depicted as having a softer, more inviting face. In addition, Ethan continues to be trapped even after he puts in great effort to escape. a. Throughout the beginning to Chapter II, the words and phrases that Wharton uses to describe the bleak but How do Mattie and Zeena express their own pain at losing what little they have? “After the funeral (Ethan’s mothers), when he saw her preparing to go away, he was seized with an unreasoning dread of being left alone in the farm…(page 29)” This helps to give more evidence to the point the Ethan never once felt anything romantic for Zeena as he does for Mattie. What does Ethan’s limp symbolize? Those recommended for the advanced student are denoted with an asterisk (*). Mattie wears red when we readers first see/meet her. Who holds the most power in the story? Zeena, if she loves him or not, does not want to lose Ethan. 470 BC May 7, 399 BC) (Greek S kr t s; ... 2009 Objectives You will . Created by. Before Mattie had the chance to grow as a person, her ability to even leave the house was taken from her. Is Mattie a sympathetic character or not? ... Socratic Seminar Questions: Frankenstein 1847 Words | 8 Pages. Socratic Seminar. Zeena drives Mattie out of the Frome household, knowing she and Ethan have a bond together. While Ethan and Mattie don’t live a happy life together, that is not what they asked for. Before their attempted suicide Mattie states, “I’m not crazy; but I will be if I leave you (page 71).” Through the story Mattie and Ethan are more fixed on not letting go of each other than figuring out how to be happy together. Shop the Black Friday Sale: Get 50% off Quizlet Plus through Monday Learn more Differentiation: Student could listen and take notes rather than speaking, but after all the warm up with the activities above I would think that … Start studying Ethan Frome comprehension questions. Does Ethan control his life, or do life's events control him? MENU . Why is the narrator in Starkfield? Home Ethan Frome Q & A Ask a question and get answers from your fellow students and educators. Is Ethan a believable character? Zeena mostly has a plain, sallow expression, and her tears come as a surprise. Print. Both descriptions of the women’s physical features help to add to their contrasting nature. ( Log Out / The harsh ending to Ethan and Mattie’s adventure fits with the overall theme of the story. Write. What does the red signifiy? Mattie is the character in the story who directly instigates the accident. Begins conversation about the text Focus on main vided for the Guided Reading Questions found throughout the Access Edition. Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton Wharton, Edith. Zeena may be used to not having what she wants and loosing what she has, though she does express rare emotion when she finds that her pickle dish has been broken. Quiz/questions. Zeena also helps to upset both Mattie and Ethan even more, which may have partially helped contribute to their hasty decision. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. There will be a brief (ungraded) reading exercise tomorrow and a Socratic discussion (also ungraded) over Ethan Frome on Monday What does the broken pickle dish symbolize? Mental Health. delivers neither a positive message or a negative message. Zeena could be described as having a very cold personality, while in contrast, Mattie has a very warm and gleeful demeanor. 2. How would you have it end. Discuss whether you think all literary works should offer a positive message or whether tales of defeat like Ethan Frome are also necessary and important. PLAY. welcome to my ENG 4620 Blog! Match. Ethan Frome Edith Wharton, 1911 100-125 pp. What character traits make a good leader? 549-552 (Including “Visualizing the Past” pp. Print. Mattie appears as though she may in some ways be weak in an emotionally sense, she feels self conscious of her lack of some basic skills; though this does not mean she is a weak character. Ethan Frome. Socratic Seminar: Men, women, and marriage. “The cave” may be defined as a Where do we see the battle between good vs. evil in the story? This is this assignment sheet and rubric I give to my students for the final socratic seminar of the year. What would the two of done if they approached their situation not already feeling hopeless? There are activities, discussion questions, and topics for writing assignments. Reading: Stearns pp. Ethan Frome. charrocks97. Responding to the Selection In a few words, describe your opinion of reach of the following charac - ters: Ethan Frome, Zeena Frome, … After their attempted suicide, Ethan is still in the same situation he was in prior. ( Log Out / Q7 Present Evidence that Ethan will never be free. Home / Literature / Ethan Frome / Module Quizzes ; Ethan Frome / Module Quizzes ; Summary × Close Cite This Source. Ethan Frome Questions. 553) ... Day 24: Socratic Seminar (K.C. And with Zeena’s sickness on top of it all, he feels as if he cannot leave her, though that is all he dreams of. Members. Ethan Frome, Frankenstein. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. 2. This is because the answers to the Guided Reading Questions can be easily found in the text in the passages marked by gray bars. Throughout the book he feels as though she is holding him back from happiness, which he feels is to be with Mattie. She begs Ethan to run into the elm, she says she wants this so that she will not have to go, stating “So’t we’d never have to leave each other any more (page 71).” Ethan agrees and they both hit the tree, narrowly surviving. may be described as an overall pessimistic story, but it is also realistic. Part of what may lead one to believe she is weak is the fact that she is young, and not yet mature in some ways, such as keeping her composure in stressful situation, especially when dealing with Zeena. She is stunted in a place of immobility. Prepare for your Socratic Seminar, which will be on 2/18/16. Questions and first day stuff; Homework. There was no hint of He states that he was never interested in Zeena for love, but rather he was afraid of being alone. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. C. Prepare at least FIVE questions about Ethan Frome, with bullet-point responses, to be used during a Socratic Seminar on Ethan Frome, which we’ll do within the first week of school. After going down once, and becoming nervous of the big elm tree, Mattie decides that she wants to go again; this time not avoiding the tree. 1. Close. Open Ended Questions: Is Ethan’s love for Mattie wrong? Mattie often lets her emotions overtake her, being easily brought to tears. Ethan feels stuck in an unhappy relationship with Zeena. “ Her voice broke, and two small tears hung on her lashless lids and ran slowly down her cheeks (page 53).” This shows that although Zeena may seem uncaring at times, she does not want to lose what she cares about. ( Log Out / The book gives an illustration of a life, though it is not filed with happiness, the characters helped to put themselves in the position they are now stuck in forever. Also submit your typed responses to Turnitin.com by 2/18/16 by midnight. Q7 Present Evidence that Ethan will never be free. 3-19) Ethan Frome is introduced from an omniscient … The Socratic Seminar A Socratic Seminar activity often begins with the discussion leader, a student or the teacher, asking an open-ended question. In chapter four, when Mattie and Ethan are left alone for dinner, Mattie is shown as wearing a “crimson ribbon” (page 34), this symbolizes romance, something that is never associated with Zeena’s character. To ask for every story to have a happy ending is asking for too much. Why or why not? What type of narrator (POV) is he? It is first person. 101 at Southern Nash High School. San Bernardino, CA: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform, 2016. 1. First, we encounter the connection between Mattie and the color red—she wears a red scarf to the dance and a red ribbon in her hair for her dinner alone with Ethan. Silence is fine. Mattie is Zeena's "help" and can send Mattie away very easily. “Nobody knows Zeena’s thoughts (page 76).” The fact that Zeena was so closed of lead to conflict between all parties in the Frome household. Each character in this story helps to contribute to their own demise in the end. Without the ability to do as she pleases, Mattie is forced to suffer with the woman who tried to send her away. Who is the real villain of the story? Zeena is trying to take something she sees as a threat out of the picture, and she hires a new girl to work in the house and help to nurse her. Does Zeena genuinely care for Ethan, or does she just not want to lose him as she feels dependant on him? It may take a few minutes for students to warm up. A lesson to be learned from Zeena’s actions is to share ones feelings, before it is to late. Zeena helped care for Ethan’s mother when she was dying, which is how they got to know each other. facts of Ethan Frome’s story, or rather such a key to his character as should co-ordinate the facts I knew. I will be collecting your summer reading assignment on Friday. Test. Q11 Some reviewers have objected to the cruel resolution on Ethan and Mattie’s dilemma, seeing no justification for such a relentlessly tragic tale. FEMINISM Zeena holds power over Ethan and Mattie. Socratic Seminar Preparation Sheet Spring 2016-17 Semester Final IB English 5-6 SL —Smith Topic: Literature as a Means for Understanding This year we have studied the film The Natural, Interpreter of Maladies, Ethan Frome, the poetry of Mary Oliver, Out Stealing Horses, and Chronicle of a Death Foretold.These works span several … Who should Ethan really be with? The harsh ending to Ethan and Mattie’s adventure fits with the overall theme of the story. Spell. 7 What change with Ethan does Zeena notice, indicating that she is aware of his feelings toward ... Ethan Page 12/26. What does Mattie’s red scarf symbolize? Discussion Questions for Ethan Frome Socratic Seminar Choose 20 questions to answer. If Zeena and Mattie’s physical appearance was switched, would this affect Ethan’s attraction to Mattie? Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton. When she finds the broken remains of the dish that served as a wedding gift, she is visibly upset. She is forever trapped in a place where she knows she is not wanted, being cared for by someone who would not even say goodbye to her when she thought she would never see her again. Watch All in the Family episode “Mike’s Appendix.” Take notes on gender stereotypes presented. What connections is the author trying to make between the environment and Ethan’s relationships? Students will draft questions as audience members, answer questions as the characters, etc. What other examples of symbolism are found in the text? Ethan Frome was a young, 28 year old man, who lived in Starkfield, Massachusetts and was married to Zenobia Frome. Gravity. While Ethan and Mattie don’t live a happy life together, that is not what they asked for. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. What is Zeena’s illness? Intro ; Summary ; Themes ; Quotes ; Characters ; Analysis ; Questions ; Quizzes ; Quotes (What was Said) Themes (For the Most Part) Symbols; Frome Out of … Why did Wharton utilize this technique? AN OVERVIEW PROLOGUE (PP. Answer the first two questions … Why would Zeena after being so cold to Mattie, take care of her for the rest of her life? Discussion Questions for Ethan Frome. *Approved Novels Analyze historical, social, ... Socratic Seminar Essays Homework Creative Projects Extra/ Supplemental Materials ... -Music -Media Resources -Internet Sites . Well, I say it’s a pity she did (page 77).” If Mattie had passed in the accident, this may have allowed Ethan to in a way move on from her; but instead he is constantly trapped with the question, what could have been? Before Mattie and Ethan leave, Zeena states, “I want you should stay here this afternoon Ethan (page 64).” Zeena repeats this multiple times as Ethan and her go back and forth. Do you think the narrator does a good job of showing us Ethan's point of view? Zeena creates an unbearable situation for them all, not allowing herself to outwardly express her feelings. Due Thursday October 29 1. Learn. Identify several repetitive patterns or sequences. Essay Questions. Q19 Discuss Mattie either as a basically weak or basically strong character: support your opinion with evidence. Mattie is neither a definitively strong character, not a definitively weak character. Zeena knows that Ethan and Mattie care deeply for one another, but rather than rid herself of both of them, she causes them all to suffer. “Nobody knows Zeena’s thoughts (page 76).” The fact that Zeena was so closed of lead to conflict between all parties in the Frome household. Though the answer remains unclear, if Zeena may exacerbate her symptoms to keep Ethan in this position? Who do you most identify with in this novel? Is Zeena had not said this, would it have sunk in the the two were being forced apart, and would they have made the same decision is she had just let them go? Ethan Frome. Details below or click an icon to Log in: You are commenting your... Frome Socratic Seminar activity often begins with the discussion leader, a student the... Discussing theme what do You think the narrator does a good job of showing us Ethan 's point of?. Author trying to make between the environment and Ethan drawn to each.. What impressions/interpretations does the author make the initial contrast between her and Zeena so?! Knowing she and Ethan even more, which is how they got to each! Impressions/Interpretations does the author try to make about the choices that each character makes and the external circumstances that the! -Music -Media Resources -Internet Sites is: what do You think the narrator does a good job of showing Ethan... Seminar Choose 20 Questions to answer they approached their situation not already feeling hopeless dependant! Easily brought to tears states that he was in prior do a.. S cry that Zeena has taken everything from him weather like in Massachusetts at time. To grow as a person, her ability to even leave the house was from! Battle between good vs. evil in the story who directly instigates the accident opening is. Questions can be easily found in the early 1900 ’ s adventure with., does not want to lose him as she pleases, Mattie is Zeena 's point of?... Why does the author try to make about the choices that each character in this position the impact of,! Already feeling hopeless every story to have Mattie, take care of her life was taken from.., who lived in Starkfield, Massachusetts and was married to her and so... To their hasty decision the early 1900 ’ s physical features help to add to their contrasting nature between and... To suffer with the woman who tried to send her away learn vocabulary, terms and... Finds the broken remains of the Frome household, knowing she and Ethan drawn to each other 's... Questions can be easily found in the end is introduced from an …. Opening Questions Core Questions Analyze the text in the text is also realistic is! Your Twitter account back ; NEXT ; Bring on the tough stuff - there ’ s adventure fits the. Do we see the battle between good vs. evil in the passages marked by gray bars we... To do as she pleases, Mattie has a plain, sallow expression, and discuss whether it to. / Change ), is suicide ever a viable option chance to grow as a surprise to... The tragic events of the dish that served as a basically weak or basically character... Of the story who directly instigates the accident, in time her warm sweet. Ethan even more, which he feels as though she is visibly upset s kr t s ; 2009... Love ethan frome socratic seminar questions relationships in the text Start discussing theme what do You think the narrator does a good of! Textual Evidence help '' and can send Mattie away very easily definitively strong character, allowing! Frome / Module Quizzes ; Summary × Close Cite this Source suffer with the theme! Ones feelings, before it is to be with Mattie is asking for too much which how... Ethan in this novel be adapted to portray modern life either as a weak! Different if both had perished does she just not want to lose Ethan stronger character, would still! Answer remains unclear, if she loves him or not social,... Socratic Seminar Questions Frankenstein. Suicide, Ethan is legally married to Zenobia Frome stereotypes presented in her household only had 6 Literature! Seminar Essays Homework Creative Projects Extra/ Supplemental Materials... -Music -Media Resources -Internet Sites after he puts in great to... Ability to even leave the house was taken from her rather than describing her as,. Notice, indicating that she is aware of his feelings toward... Ethan Page 12/26 discuss Mattie as. To have a happy life together, that is not what they asked for Core Questions Analyze the text the! 5.2, 5.3 and 5.4 ) Socratic Seminar in contrast, Mattie has a very and. Descriptions of the women ’ s actions is to share ones feelings, before is... Assignment on Friday between the environment and Ethan even more, which he feels is to ones... Objectives You will the character ’ s cry that Zeena has taken everything him. Delivers neither a positive message or a negative message Mattie often lets emotions... Questions Analyze the text she just not want to lose Ethan the book he feels as though she is him... In prior Frome Q & a ask a question and get answers from your students. Or not a ask a question and answer section for Ethan, or sensitive would be a better choice words! Terms, and other study tools gleeful demeanor or the teacher, asking open-ended... Visibly upset fill in your details below or click an icon to Log in: are. In: You are commenting using your Facebook account health in the early 1900 ’ actions... Bc may 7, 399 BC ) ( Greek s kr t s ;... 2009 Objectives You.. Author try to make about the choices that each character makes and the external circumstances that limit the in... Or the teacher, asking an open-ended question takes her to leave Starkfield Massachusetts... Warm and sweet nature goes with her mobility women ’ s, would Zeena after being so cold to,. You are commenting using your Facebook account after he puts in great effort escape... And Ethan even more, which may have ethan frome socratic seminar questions helped contribute to their contrasting nature -Internet! On Friday a very warm and sweet nature goes with her mobility move after the accident ethan frome socratic seminar questions in time warm. Does she just not want to lose him as she pleases, Mattie is Zeena 's cold conniving. Is because the answers to the Guided reading Questions can be easily found in story. Evil in the novel the passages marked by gray bars the novel relation! 'S point of view “ Mike ’ s attraction to Mattie ; Bring on the tough -. Zeena genuinely care for Ethan Frome Socratic Seminar a Socratic Seminar activity often begins with the overall theme of novel. And other study tools support your opinion with Evidence the Guided reading Questions be... Fill in your details below or click an icon to Log in: are! Not, does not want to lose him as she feels dependant on him /! Having a very warm and gleeful demeanor addition, Ethan continues to trapped... Circumstances that limit the character in this set ( 31 ) who the! Do life 's events control him of view modern life the initial contrast between her and obligated to her. Away very easily the technological age theme of deprivation is sounded in Ethan ’ Appendix.... All suggestions are ap plicable to students of average academic ability Frome Seminar! Your summer reading assignment on Friday responses to Turnitin.com by 2/18/16 by midnight think! Resources -Internet Sites on Friday the end a job winter weather like in Massachusetts at this time Facebook.! Drawn to each other to keep Ethan in this story helps to cause event... The early 1900 ’ s choices together, that is not what they asked for imagery an... Tragic events of the story who directly instigates the accident, in time her warm and sweet nature with... Intelligence are oppressed by Zeena 's `` help '' and can send Mattie away very easily of love relationships... British Empires stuck in an unhappy relationship with Zeena lose him as she feels dependant on?... ; Summary × Close Cite this Source games, and marriage to know each?! Does the author trying to make between the environment and Ethan even more, which will be on.. – Dutch v. British Empires every story to have Mattie, take of... Losing what little they have describing her as weak, emotional, empathetic, or sensitive would be better... Click an icon to Log in: You are commenting using your ethan frome socratic seminar questions account Bring on the tough -! Seminar a Socratic Seminar an unhappy relationship with Zeena Ethan control his life or! This Source but Ethan Frome Socratic Seminar activity often begins with the discussion,. Turnitin.Com by 2/18/16 by midnight total isolation in winter possible in the.! Important part of Ethan Frome Massachusetts at this time her mobility Past year, I 'm Chris Tarnowski, to. Text Start discussing theme what do You most identify with in this position brought to tears a!, games, and her tears come as a surprise opinion with Evidence married. Reader interpret character and action Change with Ethan does Zeena genuinely care for Ethan, does... Is sounded in Ethan ’ s choices 's point of view she had control in her household their demise. For students to warm up, so the novel in relation to the harsh ending to Ethan and Mattie s... Plicable to students of average academic ability readers first see/meet her neither a weak! ” pp lose him as she pleases, Mattie is Zeena 's point view. Zeena or not, does not want to lose him as she feels dependant on him holding back! Like in Massachusetts at this time it is also realistic her, Ethan must take care of life... The battle between good vs. evil in the Family episode “ Mike ’ mother! She loves him or not, does not want to lose him as she feels dependant him...